[00:00:24 CEST] <phisch> kepstin: that could explain it, but default behavior should be that background tasks don't receive the sigint afaik [00:00:34 CEST] <phisch> don't know why this should be different for me [00:01:34 CEST] <kepstin> but that would explain the behaviour - if ffmpeg receives *two* SIGINT, the first starts a clean exit, but the second aborts that and exits immediately [00:02:11 CEST] <phisch> yeah, but i don't know how i could check/prevent this [00:03:05 CEST] <phisch> i think this is very ffmpeg related [00:05:28 CEST] <kepstin> I explained ffmpeg's behaviour ^^ [00:06:31 CEST] <phisch> do you know if there is a way to disable this behavior then? :P [00:07:12 CEST] <phisch> or could you run the script, hit ctrl+c and tell me your output? just to make sure that this is not some messed up stuff related to my system [00:07:14 CEST] <kepstin> I'm really not familiar enough with how the process group stuff in the shell works to give a suggestion :/ [00:07:26 CEST] <kepstin> this is the expected behaviour with your script, i think. [00:11:06 CEST] <phisch> no, i expect that when my script receives a sigint (either by `kill -INT [PID]` or `ctrl+c`) the sigint trap handles gracefully killing background processes [00:23:20 CEST] <kepstin> hmm. i really dislike working with signal handling. I can't even get that working when just running 'sleep' instead of ffmpeg :/ [00:25:53 CEST] <kepstin> phisch: you might have better results if you remove the 'wait $FFMPEG_PID' from the signal handler [00:26:48 CEST] <phisch> i need to wait until it's completely done though [00:27:05 CEST] <kepstin> don't wait in the signal handler :/ [00:27:46 CEST] <phisch> i have to, since i want to run the script via a shortcut and kill it with another one [00:28:22 CEST] <kepstin> not sure what you mean. you shouldn't need to wait in the signal handler, you're already waiting at the end of the script [00:32:21 CEST] <phisch> you hit a shortcut, select a screen area with slop, it records that screen area with ffmpeg, once the process is killed via another shortcut the trap sends a sigint to ffmpeg and then waits until the process has fully exited, then takes the video and makes a gif out of it [00:33:16 CEST] <kepstin> ah, the issue is that the signal handler interrupts the wait at the bottom of the script and it doesn't get resumed :/ [00:33:40 CEST] <phisch> yes, thats why i need the wait in the signal handler [00:34:28 CEST] <phisch> and everything works for my use-case, but i'd really like to also be able to use this from a terminal directly and having it work with hitting ctrl+c [00:34:42 CEST] <phisch> but as we have seen the ctrl+c somehow sends 2 sigints to ffmpeg [00:34:55 CEST] <phisch> because ffmpeg does some magic or whatever [00:39:01 CEST] <kepstin> just to confirm, you want to run some other commands in the same script after ffmpeg exits? [00:41:48 CEST] <kepstin> probably the easiest solution is to run the ffmpeg command under nohup (like `nohup ffmpeg <args> &`), that'll make all the signals work the way you expect. Note that nohup by default sends the command output to a file named nohup.out. [00:42:27 CEST] <kepstin> (bit of a big hammer for this, since you probably would want ffmpeg to be killed if you close the terminal, but it'll work) [00:44:46 CEST] <phisch> yeah, detaching with nohup seems like something worth trying [00:45:21 CEST] <phisch> and yes, i want to run more commands, my example is just a stripped down version to illustrate the problem without unnecessary stuff [00:47:01 CEST] Action: kepstin has confirmed that it works - if you still want the command output in the terminal, `nohup ffmpeg ... | cat &` is a hilarious way of doing it. [00:47:35 CEST] <kepstin> i assume there must be a way to do this without nohup, but..? :/ [00:48:02 CEST] <phisch> yeah, without would be perfect [01:49:30 CEST] <kevinnn> does anyone know if vlc streams rtsp using UDP by default? [01:49:43 CEST] <kevinnn> and if it does how can I set it to use TCP? [03:10:12 CEST] <memelover> I'm attempting to transcode some FLACs to ALAC. The specific command I'm using is "ffmpeg -i song.flac -acodec alac -map 0:0 song.m4a. This seems to preserve most of the tags, but not all. For example, the "total tracks" tag does not appear in the m4a.Is there some gotcha that I'm missing? [03:11:52 CEST] <memelover> It also appears to gut the replaygain data. [03:17:21 CEST] <klaxa> there is a -map_metadata flag, maybe look into that? [03:18:10 CEST] <klaxa> https://ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg.html#Advanced-options [03:21:40 CEST] <memelover> Hmm. It says that if not included, it defaults to including all metadata. [03:24:53 CEST] <klaxa> -map 0:0 excludes everything but track 0 from file 0 though [03:25:05 CEST] <klaxa> not sure if that also excludes metadata, but maybe? [03:25:15 CEST] <klaxa> but if you tried and it didn't help, guess not [03:33:18 CEST] <memelover> Well, my reason for doing that is that track 1 sometimes contains an mjpeg album cover, which ffmpeg really doesn't like. It cannot seem to process it at all, so my plan is to add it back in after transcoding. [03:34:27 CEST] <memelover> And it looks like the replaygain data isn't actually metadata, but information inside the audio track. Even -fflags keepside doesn't seem to help with that. [03:41:03 CEST] <phisch> kepstin: wait, how did you get nohup to work? [06:25:59 CEST] <damdai> anybody know what it means by "fragmented" and "cbcs" ? http://download.opencontent.netflix.com/?prefix=AV1/Chimera/ [07:29:16 CEST] <damdai> what is wrong with ffmpeg devs? [07:29:29 CEST] <damdai> they closed my bug report for no reaosn [07:32:13 CEST] <damdai> dongs you there? [08:39:15 CEST] <pkunk> Does "-use_wallclock_as_timestamps 1" work with mpegts streams? [08:40:44 CEST] <pkunk> I sometimes get "non-monotonous" packet errors on output. So tried this option, but with this I instead get "DTS discontinuity in stream 1" errors as the mpegts packets sometimes come in out of order over http [08:42:03 CEST] <pkunk> Or is there any other way to "fix" the timestamps on mpegts streams so I can avoid the dreaded "non-monotonic" errors on av_interleaved_write_frame() [10:04:33 CEST] <JEEB> pkunk: if it's wrap-around that's standard in MPEG-TS in theory libavformat has wrap-around handling but that only seems to work once. ffmpeg.c then attempts to do it again in a separate piece of logic. [10:05:15 CEST] <JEEB> for that specific option what it does is it overrides the timestamp in libavformat's utils [10:05:28 CEST] <JEEB> in other words if you have b-frames etc it will just bork [10:05:31 CEST] <JEEB> pkt->dts = pkt->pts = av_rescale_q(av_gettime(), AV_TIME_BASE_Q, st->time_base); [10:06:18 CEST] <JEEB> so yes the option will "work" for MPEG-TS input, but I think of this as something that an API client would handle rather than the framework (I like the way upipe has three timestamps) [10:06:43 CEST] <JEEB> (in upipe each packet has three timestamps: original coded, coded+wrap-arounds etc handled, receipt time) [10:07:41 CEST] <JEEB> that way the API client can still know the original timestamps but attempt to normalize the stream in case the input timestamps are actually broken [11:50:12 CEST] <pkunk> JEEB: Thanks JEEB . I'm using the console ffmpeg right now, modified to do parallel open of all input streams [11:51:57 CEST] <pkunk> Excuse the additional nickname, Will have a look at what "upipe" is . First time I've heard of it [11:57:44 CEST] <cartman412> Hi there! I've been making a gif maker using ffmpeg and I noticed that for some reason, when I try to add padding the final output quality seems to lower drastically. Here are the commands I use (no padding/padding): https://pastebin.com/3rrAJ0df / https://pastebin.com/uYg8PZuq and a screenshot of the resulting gifs (no padding/padding): https://pasteboard.co/I9CCPmr.png / https://pasteboard.co/I9CD8xK.png [11:58:20 CEST] <cartman412> Also note how the padding color seems to leak into the actual video on the left side [11:58:28 CEST] <cartman412> Any ideas of what I might be doing wrong? [11:58:49 CEST] <JEEB> pkunk: it's a more broadcast-oriented multimedia framework that has modules for decoding through FFmpeg etc [11:58:55 CEST] <JEEB> it has some nice ideas [11:59:11 CEST] <furq> cartman412: you probably want to pad before calling paletteuse [11:59:56 CEST] <cartman412> that was what I was thinking, thanks for confirming it :) I'll try this now! [12:08:08 CEST] <cartman412> furq your suggestion fixed the quality and pad color leaking into the actual image, but now the padding color seems to be affected instead [12:08:41 CEST] <furq> yeah it sounds like the problem is that the pad color isn't in the generated palette [12:08:41 CEST] <cartman412> https://pasteboard.co/I9CJAB7.png [12:08:59 CEST] <cartman412> so I should add padding when generating the palette as well? [12:09:05 CEST] <furq> that should work [12:09:22 CEST] <cartman412> awesome, thanks for the quick answers :) [12:16:48 CEST] <cartman412> furq: it worked! https://pasteboard.co/I9CMJz4.png thank you so much! :) [13:19:01 CEST] <Atlenohen> Any idea what this does in ffmpeg's config? --extra-cflags='-MT -IWindowsInclude -GS-' [13:19:18 CEST] <Atlenohen> Build config [13:22:24 CEST] <furq> they're just extra arguments to your c preprocessor/compiler [13:22:26 CEST] <pink_mist> sets flags for the C compiler [13:22:31 CEST] <pink_mist> yeah, or preprocessor [13:22:58 CEST] <pink_mist> what exactly they do to your C preprocessor or compiler, you'd haveto read its documentation or ask on its support forums [13:24:40 CEST] <furq> if this is msvc then -MT uses the static runtime library and -GS disables buffer security checking [13:24:57 CEST] <furq> i assume -I is the same as gcc (sets a header include directory) [13:39:20 CEST] <King_DuckZ> hi, anyone knows what the -profile:v 3 option would be set in code? I'm using the library directly [15:05:22 CEST] <th3_v0ice> Why would avformat_find_stream_info() fail for a same file that FFmpeg reads properly? Both are from the same version 4.0. [15:34:56 CEST] <pranayvshah> How can I get ass->shaping to hold a value of 1 that is "shaping complex" in here https://github.com/FFmpeg/FFmpeg/blob/release/4.1/libavfilter/vf_subtitles.c... [15:35:57 CEST] <JEEB> pranayvshah: set the shaping option to the value "complex" [15:36:27 CEST] <pranayvshah> That option works for the ass filter. I need it to work for the subtitles filter [15:36:28 CEST] <JEEB> oh, that is specific to the ass filter [15:36:30 CEST] <JEEB> right [15:36:43 CEST] <JEEB> just noticed the name of the struct that defines the option :) [15:37:00 CEST] <pranayvshah> Yeah :P [15:37:24 CEST] <JEEB> wonder why it was added as ass-only [15:37:59 CEST] <pranayvshah> I nevertheless tried the same option on the subtitles filter, did not work :D [15:39:28 CEST] <JEEB> ok, sounds like you could try moving the option from ass_options to COMMON_OPTIONS [15:40:04 CEST] <JEEB> if it really works as an option for the other filter that you're utilizing [15:40:05 CEST] <JEEB> :) [15:40:58 CEST] <JEEB> which would effectively make ass_options into COMMON_OPTIONS and then nullptr [15:41:09 CEST] <pranayvshah> As a workaround, I simply set removed the ass->shaping argument and replaced it with 1. That's a lot simpler for me since I know libass is compiled with harfbuzz [15:41:36 CEST] <JEEB> if the option works then we might want to move it into the common options [15:41:48 CEST] <JEEB> if you think that's a useful change and it isn't specific to the ass filter [15:42:42 CEST] <pranayvshah> This does work for me - ass_set_shaper(ass->renderer, 1); [15:43:06 CEST] <JEEB> ok, might post a patch on the mailing list moving the option into the common one [15:43:09 CEST] <JEEB> *common list [15:43:16 CEST] <pranayvshah> I was hoping to not have to use my own compiled version [15:53:57 CEST] <bencoh> 41 [16:08:09 CEST] <Atlenohen> Does this still hold true? http://www.ffmpeg-archive.org/ffvhuff-codec-improvement-td4661530.html FFV1 doesn't operate on per-frame level? And the force intra-frame only is not a 100% workaround? [16:11:29 CEST] <furq> what does "operate on per-frame level" mean [16:12:27 CEST] <DHE> and this is talking mostly about pixel formats [16:12:47 CEST] <DHE> oh, this bit about precise and fast seeking I assume... [16:35:33 CEST] <Atlenohen> Yeah, [16:36:18 CEST] <furq> what makes you think setting the gop size isn't a workaround [16:36:39 CEST] <Atlenohen> I was about to mention that, if the GOP size has anything to do wiht it [16:37:09 CEST] <Atlenohen> I guess good then [16:37:29 CEST] <furq> i mean i don't know that it is [16:37:33 CEST] <furq> i just didn't see that in the thread [16:37:51 CEST] <furq> it ought to work fine with a gop size of 1 [17:03:36 CEST] <HickHoward> uhhhhhhh [20:50:11 CEST] <HickHoward> uhh [20:50:57 CEST] <HickHoward> how can i encode a mpeg2 video file with a custom intra quantizer matrix? [20:52:57 CEST] <HickHoward> wait a second [20:53:00 CEST] <HickHoward> nevermind [21:17:05 CEST] <HickHoward> anyways i'm having a bit of a problem with this filter [21:17:06 CEST] <HickHoward> file:///H:/ffmpeg/doc/ffmpeg-filters.html#toc-il [21:17:32 CEST] <HickHoward> so, with ffmpeg's current version i'm supposed to just use "-vf 'il'" or something? [21:18:46 CEST] <HickHoward> i say this because i tried other options 'il' has in offer like chroma_mode and interleave but none of them work [21:18:48 CEST] <HickHoward> like this [21:18:57 CEST] <HickHoward> "-vf "il=chroma_mode=interleave"" [21:21:12 CEST] <durandal_1707> pastebin full command and ffmpeg output [21:21:24 CEST] <HickHoward> wait [21:21:33 CEST] <HickHoward> ffmpeg.exe -i "H:\Tourist Trophy (Japan)\tt_vol\openingW.m2v" -vf 'il=chroma_mode:interleave' openingW.avi [21:21:35 CEST] <HickHoward> no [21:21:38 CEST] <HickHoward> sorry [21:21:47 CEST] <HickHoward> you meant pastebin [21:22:06 CEST] <HickHoward> https://pastebin.com/TaQKq8VD [21:23:09 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: il=chroma_mode=interleave [21:23:45 CEST] <HickHoward> pastebin edited [21:23:48 CEST] <HickHoward> doesn't work for me either [21:24:29 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: you forgot to paste and ffmpeg output of command [21:25:02 CEST] <HickHoward> just the ffmpeg output of command [21:25:11 CEST] <HickHoward> okay [21:26:02 CEST] <HickHoward> pastebin updated [21:29:25 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: ffmpeg.exe -i "H:\Tourist Trophy (Japan)\tt_vol\openingW.m2v" -vf "il=chroma_mode:interleave" openingW.avi [21:30:28 CEST] <HickHoward> done [21:30:31 CEST] <HickHoward> pastebin updated [21:36:50 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: Sorry, use: ffmpeg.exe -i "H:\Tourist Trophy (Japan)\tt_vol\openingW.m2v" -vf "il=chroma_mode=interleave" openingW.avi [21:37:55 CEST] <HickHoward> okay, *now* it works [21:39:53 CEST] <HickHoward> well, i feel like i haven't communicated my idea with this yet [21:40:00 CEST] <HickHoward> so, the source file looks like this [21:40:01 CEST] <HickHoward> https://i.boring.host/WS8WD5U.png [21:40:21 CEST] <HickHoward> what you're seeing here is *two* frames being combined into one [21:40:33 CEST] <HickHoward> and the frame rate is halved [21:40:36 CEST] <HickHoward> because of this [21:41:08 CEST] <HickHoward> (as in, the original frame rate of this source file is 29.98 fps) [21:41:16 CEST] <HickHoward> *29.97 fps [21:42:31 CEST] <durandal_1707> use weave/doubleweave [21:42:38 CEST] <HickHoward> okay [21:44:40 CEST] <HickHoward> tested it, all that ever did was double the horizontal screen size of the output file [21:44:55 CEST] <HickHoward> *all that ever did => all that weave/doubleweave [21:49:10 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: il=1:1:1 [21:49:25 CEST] <HickHoward> hold on [21:49:27 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: il=1:1:1,separatefields [21:49:42 CEST] <HickHoward> okay, testing now [21:54:26 CEST] <HickHoward> tested, now the frame organization is wrong as all hell(first frame is bottom, second frame is top, and so on until the end of video) so i had to put setfield=tff before separatefields [21:57:45 CEST] <durandal_1707> HickHoward: so it works? if not upload first 20 frames somewhere [21:57:54 CEST] <HickHoward> yes [22:16:15 CEST] <HickHoward> okay, now i've done this [22:16:17 CEST] <HickHoward> ffmpeg.exe -i "H:\Tourist Trophy (Japan)\tt_vol\openingW.m2v" -vf "il=1:1:1,setfield=tff,separatefields" -vcodec rawvideo -pix_fmt bgr24 openingW.avi [22:16:36 CEST] <HickHoward> and now i want the output video to remain its input resolution(640x448) [22:19:06 CEST] <cptnhmr42> Does anyone know if there are any patches out there for dealing with AV sync issues when converting RTMP to HLS / MPEG-DASH? [23:08:34 CEST] <faLUCE> Hello. If a GPL non-commercial library uses ffmpeg/x264, does it have to contact/pay something to MPEG LA ? [23:09:46 CEST] <faLUCE> it seems that MPEG LA's license doesn't talk about FOSS projects, and requires a fee only for big commercial ones [23:11:42 CEST] <JEEB> software licensing is unrelated to patent licensing due to distributing binaries [23:12:30 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: and what does this cause? [23:13:24 CEST] <JEEB> that whether something is open source or not doesn't matter. you look if <patent licensing for thing X> is applicable to you (maybe consult a lawyer if you care enough) regardless [23:14:25 CEST] <JEEB> I don't know your laws and whether such licensing is applicable in your country to begin with [23:14:51 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: for example, in France? [23:15:07 CEST] <JEEB> VideoLAN seems to be on the stance of middle fingering [23:15:15 CEST] <JEEB> given that they are not paying for VLC distribution [23:16:02 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: but what if a library doesn't provide binaries? [23:16:13 CEST] <JEEB> then at least with MPEG-LA you have no problems [23:16:17 CEST] <JEEB> they license binary distribution [23:16:32 CEST] <JEEB> at least according to a quote from donald graft on doom9 ages ago [23:16:51 CEST] <JEEB> if you start caring about patent licensing of course, then there's way more than just MPEG-LA :P [23:17:46 CEST] <JEEB> it's a messy thing if you really want to start looking into it [23:18:03 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: yes, I tried to understand but it's too messy [23:18:19 CEST] <faLUCE> after reading several posts I did not get any conclusion [23:18:22 CEST] <JEEB> well, the MPEG-LA rules in general are pretty simple [23:18:25 CEST] <JEEB> for H.264 at least [23:18:55 CEST] <faLUCE> which are them? [23:19:00 CEST] <JEEB> https://www.mpegla.com/wp-content/uploads/avcweb.pdf [23:19:08 CEST] <JEEB> this is the brief overview [23:19:43 CEST] <JEEB> for example for encoders you pay nothing if you distribute 0-100k binaries :P [23:20:04 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: where is the word "binary" in that doc? [23:20:29 CEST] <JEEB> "Products sold to end users" is basically binary distribution to end user [23:20:46 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: in this case thekeyword is "sold", not "binary" [23:21:05 CEST] <JEEB> yes, but you can sell it for $0. it's made for businesses that generally don't set the price at $0 :P [23:21:11 CEST] <JEEB> of course [23:21:17 CEST] <JEEB> nothign stops you from *asking* MPEG-LA [23:22:17 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: but why a library is not a "product" ? [23:22:25 CEST] <JEEB> ? [23:22:36 CEST] <JEEB> I don't think whether it's a library or not matters [23:23:18 CEST] <faLUCE> so, it's not clear if open source code is not a "product sold to end user" [23:23:25 CEST] <faLUCE> (encoder) [23:23:31 CEST] <JEEB> I will have to find the quote [23:23:39 CEST] <JEEB> but MPEG-LA has said that they don't care about *source* [23:23:40 CEST] <durandal_1707> faLUCE: you need to pay for any non-foss codec usage as user to my address [23:24:26 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: yes, in fact I understood that MPEG LA wants to be payed for non FOSS [23:24:37 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: but where is it specified in their license? [23:24:47 CEST] <faLUCE> it doesn't talk about foss or non foss [23:25:16 CEST] <JEEB> https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=156599 [23:25:34 CEST] <JEEB> yea, MPEG-LA does not care if the distributed software (binaries) is OSS or not [23:26:32 CEST] <durandal_1707> OSS is irrelevant to them, they count only implementations [23:27:06 CEST] <JEEB> well, as I noted (this is not legal advice) they don't really care about open source (by non-corps) [23:27:13 CEST] <JEEB> or well, it would be stupid to go after them [23:27:43 CEST] <faLUCE> [23:27] <JEEB> well, as I noted (this is not legal advice) they don't really care about open source (by non-corps) <--- this is true, but tehy could, if they want [23:28:08 CEST] <JEEB> yes [23:28:16 CEST] <JEEB> if they would want to enforce it they 100% could attempt to [23:28:25 CEST] <JEEB> whether such patent licensing is valid in your country is the key [23:28:29 CEST] <JEEB> > Ryan has just clarified that indeed source code is not a "product" in the required sense. He clarified that anybody creating a product using FFMPEG source code is a supplier, so anyone compiling and supplying the binary library would be subject to licensing. [23:28:42 CEST] <JEEB> this is the quoting from MPEG-LA [23:29:40 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: so, if a library wraps ffmpeg, there are not binaries or "products" [23:29:56 CEST] <JEEB> faLUCE: until someone produces a binary and distributes it to users, yup [23:30:05 CEST] <JEEB> source code only is something that MPEG-LA does not care about [23:30:41 CEST] <JEEB> or at least this was the case in 2010 [23:31:01 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: in case MPEG LA cares about source code, it would stop/break projects like vlc,ffmpeg, mplayer and tons of other stuff downloaded by million of users [23:31:20 CEST] <faLUCE> this would be absurd [23:31:25 CEST] <durandal_1707> really? [23:32:13 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: so this is the reason for which they don't do anything [23:32:30 CEST] <faLUCE> ? [23:34:01 CEST] <durandal_1707> sometimes they ask authors to remove source code implementing certain codecs [23:34:22 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: which codecs for example? [23:34:59 CEST] <durandal_1707> any random one =p [23:36:06 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: but they asked that to ffmpeg too? [23:36:42 CEST] <durandal_1707> yea [23:37:03 CEST] <faLUCE> and did ffmpeg remove the code? [23:37:45 CEST] <durandal_1707> nope [23:38:06 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: and they (MPEG LA) did not do anything else? [23:38:43 CEST] <durandal_1707> uhg, i dunno about MPEG LA, I was talking about other companies [23:39:29 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: so there's a fight between companies and ffmpeg [23:40:33 CEST] <durandal_1707> more like fight with authors of certain REd code [23:41:06 CEST] <HickHoward> gotta protect my codecs! [23:41:23 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: but do they have really power to begin a legal action against ffmpeg ? [23:42:01 CEST] <durandal_1707> dunno, anything can change [23:43:31 CEST] <faLUCE> then it's a very obscure situation :-( [23:44:36 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: from what "ryan" of the linked discussion say, that companies could not do anything [23:46:32 CEST] <faLUCE> let's ask to x264 channel too... [23:47:08 CEST] <durandal_1707> x264 is encoder, while i mainly talked about decoders [23:47:36 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: what's the difference, in terms of legal stuff? [23:48:50 CEST] <durandal_1707> dunno, for important legal stuff ask lawyers [23:49:50 CEST] <durandal_1707> short story: if you make money on ffmpeg, they will come after you... [23:50:01 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: this is not my case [23:50:11 CEST] <faLUCE> and I understood that [23:51:11 CEST] <faLUCE> durandal_1707: but I wondered if is there anything in their licens/docs that assures that if you DON'T provide binaries and DON'T make money , you won't have probles [23:51:16 CEST] <faLUCE> problems [23:51:32 CEST] <JEEB> of course not, why would they write that :D [23:52:05 CEST] <JEEB> but at least the binary distribution is a requirement for *MPEG-LA* [23:52:12 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: for completeness [23:52:16 CEST] <JEEB> so it doesn't matter for MPEG-LA if you're OSS or not [23:52:27 CEST] <JEEB> if you don't distribute binaries you're not distributing to end users [23:52:34 CEST] <JEEB> that's an early exit :P [23:52:46 CEST] <JEEB> (not legal advice but that's how a lot of people read it) [23:53:05 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: it seems more a "common thought" that the reality [23:53:35 CEST] <JEEB> faLUCE: for you, not for MPEG-LA or any other licensor. for the licensor it is much better if there are cases where someone is unsure, and thus they are more likely to license [23:53:46 CEST] <JEEB> for possible licensees it is of course worse [23:53:47 CEST] <JEEB> :P [23:54:09 CEST] <JEEB> thus it becomes a legal thing and the only ones that can advise you on that are lawyers [23:55:21 CEST] <JEEB> or if you want MPEG-LA's opinion, ask them [23:55:32 CEST] <faLUCE> but in the case they want to require license from one of these GPL non-commercial products, they would have to do that for all of them [23:56:04 CEST] <JEEB> dunno, I don't know if there are such requirements in laws [23:56:14 CEST] <JEEB> I Am Not A Lawyer (IANAL) [23:56:43 CEST] <faLUCE> JEEB: anyway, "Ryan has just clarified that indeed source code is not a "product" in the required sense. He clarified that anybody creating a product using FFMPEG source code is a supplier, so anyone compiling and supplying the binary library would be subject to licensing." <-- it doesn't quote ryan's words [23:56:50 CEST] <JEEB> true [23:57:00 CEST] <JEEB> he did leave ryan's contact though [23:57:09 CEST] <JEEB> feel free to request a new quotable thing [23:57:23 CEST] <JEEB> if you want MPEG-LA's opinion on things [00:00:00 CEST] --- Fri Apr 12 2019
participants (1)
-
burek