We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file *ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]* That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire. First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on... Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages? Thanks Roman
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times, because some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency. -Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
Yes it is always the case. The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the wireshark rtp analyzer. As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms... "Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status" "28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214" "46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214" "47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214" "48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214" "49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214" "63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214" "64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214" "65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214" "66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214" "81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214" 2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times, because some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity. _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes it is always the case.
The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the wireshark rtp analyzer.
As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms...
"Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status"
"28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214"
2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times,
because
some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul --
Please dont post, it become difficult for other users searching for similar problem they cant understand the context, even it for other user. Who would have helped you bur cant since the context get lost According to ur ws log, i dont have sollution so that you can make delta equal, to me it look like one frame of audio takes 12 packet to get transmitted, so delta in 12 packet is only due network latency, while there is some time taken by transcoder for each frame so after each frame u get a bigger transcoder. There are 2 way to decrease delta Either buy more fast hardware so that transcoder take less per frame time. Keep transcodec audio at your server end, only add rtp header when you required streaming. There is also an misunderstanding that lower the bitrate faster will be the transfer, u should keep in mind that lower is the bitrate more hardwork on encoder so lower the production of frame, whenever u have to transcoder and stream then there must be good balance of bitrate, most of the time selection of bitrate is done by system to be used. Try -avcodec copy for not transcoding. -Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
Thanks for your answer. The network and the server hardware are not the problem. The problem is that ffmpeg streams the packets in burst. We are looking for a way that the stream is send in real-time. So all 19 to 20ms one packet! Any Idea? 2014-02-28 19:45 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes it is always the case.
The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the wireshark rtp analyzer.
As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms...
"Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status"
"28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214"
2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times,
because
some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul --
Please dont post, it become difficult for other users searching for similar problem they cant understand the context, even it for other user. Who would have helped you bur cant since the context get lost
According to ur ws log, i dont have sollution so that you can make delta equal, to me it look like one frame of audio takes 12 packet to get transmitted, so delta in 12 packet is only due network latency, while there is some time taken by transcoder for each frame so after each frame u get a bigger transcoder. There are 2 way to decrease delta Either buy more fast hardware so that transcoder take less per frame time.
Keep transcodec audio at your server end, only add rtp header when you required streaming.
There is also an misunderstanding that lower the bitrate faster will be the transfer, u should keep in mind that lower is the bitrate more hardwork on encoder so lower the production of frame, whenever u have to transcoder and stream then there must be good balance of bitrate, most of the time selection of bitrate is done by system to be used.
Try -avcodec copy for not transcoding.
-Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity. _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Thanks for your answer. The network and the server hardware are not the problem. The problem is that ffmpeg streams the packets in burst. We are looking for a way that the stream is send in real-time. So all 19 to 20ms one packet! Any Idea? 2014-02-28 19:45 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes it is always the case.
The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the wireshark rtp analyzer.
As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms...
"Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status"
"28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214"
2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times,
because
some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul --
Please dont post, it become difficult for other users searching for similar problem they cant understand the context, even it for other user. Who would have helped you bur cant since the context get lost
According to ur ws log, i dont have sollution so that you can make delta equal, to me it look like one frame of audio takes 12 packet to get transmitted, so delta in 12 packet is only due network latency, while there is some time taken by transcoder for each frame so after each frame u get a bigger transcoder. There are 2 way to decrease delta Either buy more fast hardware so that transcoder take less per frame time.
Keep transcodec audio at your server end, only add rtp header when you required streaming.
There is also an misunderstanding that lower the bitrate faster will be the transfer, u should keep in mind that lower is the bitrate more hardwork on encoder so lower the production of frame, whenever u have to transcoder and stream then there must be good balance of bitrate, most of the time selection of bitrate is done by system to be used.
Try -avcodec copy for not transcoding.
-Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity. _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
We are still struggling with this problem, that we cant send a continues rtp stream to a destination. The packets are always send in burst of about 12 packets in 0.6 ms. We cant find a parameter were we could regulate the stream regularity. Ideas, hints or just tell us that it wont work as wished, so we don't have to search anymore... 2014-03-20 14:50 GMT+01:00 the... <ttmgybta@gmail.com>:
Thanks for your answer.
The network and the server hardware are not the problem. The problem is that ffmpeg streams the packets in burst.
We are looking for a way that the stream is send in real-time. So all 19 to 20ms one packet! Any Idea?
2014-02-28 19:45 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes it is always the case.
The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the wireshark rtp analyzer.
As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms...
"Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status"
"28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214"
2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722 -ar 16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then the next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between the packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times,
because
some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul --
Please dont post, it become difficult for other users searching for similar problem they cant understand the context, even it for other user. Who would have helped you bur cant since the context get lost
According to ur ws log, i dont have sollution so that you can make delta equal, to me it look like one frame of audio takes 12 packet to get transmitted, so delta in 12 packet is only due network latency, while there is some time taken by transcoder for each frame so after each frame u get a bigger transcoder. There are 2 way to decrease delta Either buy more fast hardware so that transcoder take less per frame time.
Keep transcodec audio at your server end, only add rtp header when you required streaming.
There is also an misunderstanding that lower the bitrate faster will be the transfer, u should keep in mind that lower is the bitrate more hardwork on encoder so lower the production of frame, whenever u have to transcoder and stream then there must be good balance of bitrate, most of the time selection of bitrate is done by system to be used.
Try -avcodec copy for not transcoding.
-Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity. _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We are still struggling with this problem, that we cant send a continues rtp stream to a destination. The packets are always send in burst of about 12 packets in 0.6 ms. We cant find a parameter were we could regulate the stream regularity.
Ideas, hints or just tell us that it wont work as wished, so we don't have to search anymore...
2014-03-20 14:50 GMT+01:00 the... <ttmgybta@gmail.com>:
Thanks for your answer.
The network and the server hardware are not the problem. The problem
that ffmpeg streams the packets in burst.
We are looking for a way that the stream is send in real-time. So all 19 to 20ms one packet! Any Idea?
2014-02-28 19:45 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes it is always the case.
The log below is a part of the csv which I exported from the
wireshark
rtp analyzer.
As you can see from Sequence 0 to 11 we have a delta from about 0.02ms the 244ms and the about 0.02 abayn and then 244ms...
"Packet","Sequence","Time stamp","Delta (ms)","Jitter (ms)","Skew(ms)","IP BW (kbps)","Marker","Status"
"28","0","3893850368","0.00","0.00","0.00","1.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"29","1","3893850528","0.02","1.25","19.98","3.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"30","2","3893850688","0.03","2.42","39.95","4.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"31","3","3893850848","0.10","3.51","59.85","6.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"32","4","3893851008","0.02","4.54","79.83","8.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"33","5","3893851168","0.08","5.50","99.75","9.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"34","6","3893851328","0.05","6.41","119.70","11.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"35","7","3893851488","0.04","7.25","139.66","12.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"36","8","3893851648","0.08","8.04","159.59","14.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"37","9","3893851808","0.04","8.79","179.55","16.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"38","10","3893851968","0.06","9.49","199.48","17.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"39","11","3893852128","0.04","10.14","219.45","19.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.511","214"
"46","12","3893852288","244.30","23.53","-4.86","20.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"47","13","3893852448","0.05","23.30","15.09","22.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"48","14","3893852608","0.01","23.09","35.07","24.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.755","214"
"49","15","3893852768","0.08","22.90","54.99","25.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"50","16","3893852928","0.04","22.71","74.95","27.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"51","17","3893853088","0.07","22.54","94.89","28.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"52","18","3893853248","0.04","22.38","114.85","30.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"53","19","3893853408","0.07","22.23","134.78","32.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"54","20","3893853568","0.09","22.08","154.69","33.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"55","21","3893853728","0.04","21.95","174.65","35.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"56","22","3893853888","0.06","21.82","194.60","36.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"57","23","3893854048","0.04","21.71","214.56","38.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"58","24","3893854208","0.07","21.60","234.49","40.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:57.756","214"
"63","25","3893854368","255.35","34.96","-0.86","41.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"64","26","3893854528","0.05","34.02","19.09","43.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"65","27","3893854688","0.01","33.14","39.08","44.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.011","214"
"66","28","3893854848","0.07","32.32","59.01","46.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"67","29","3893855008","0.06","31.54","78.95","48.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"68","30","3893855168","0.06","30.82","98.89","49.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"69","31","3893855328","0.04","30.14","118.86","51.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"70","32","3893855488","0.08","29.50","138.78","52.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"71","33","3893855648","0.09","28.90","158.69","54.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"72","34","3893855808","0.04","28.34","178.65","56.00","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"73","35","3893855968","0.03","27.82","198.61","57.60","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"74","36","3893856128","0.10","27.32","218.51","59.20","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"75","37","3893856288","0.02","26.86","238.50","60.80","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.012","214"
"81","38","3893856448","255.38","39.90","3.12","62.40","","[ Ok ]","02/20/2014 16:17:58.267","214"
2014-02-28 17:02 GMT+01:00 Anshul <anshul.ffmpeg@gmail.com>:
"the..." <ttmgybta@gmail.com> wrote:
We see in the tcpdump that when we stream a wav file
*ffmpeg -analyzeduration 0 -re -i /tmp/test.wav -vol 512 -c g722
-ar
16000 -f rtp rtp://[destIP]:[destPort]*
That the stream is sending in burst in to the wire.
First about 12 packages in 0.6ms then about 144ms delta and then
next 12 package in 0.6ms delta for about 144ms and so on...
Is it possible to send the stream with a constant delta between
packages?
Thanks
Roman _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Is this case is allways same? i mean have you tried many times, because some time diffence in latency is by underlying operating system which have an unreliable network latency.
-Anshul --
Please dont post, it become difficult for other users searching for similar problem they cant understand the context, even it for other user. Who would have helped you bur cant since the context get lost
According to ur ws log, i dont have sollution so that you can make delta equal, to me it look like one frame of audio takes 12 packet to get transmitted, so delta in 12 packet is only due network latency, while there is some time taken by transcoder for each frame so after each frame u get a bigger transcoder. There are 2 way to decrease delta Either buy more fast hardware so that transcoder take less per frame time.
Keep transcodec audio at your server end, only add rtp header when you required streaming.
There is also an misunderstanding that lower the bitrate faster will be the transfer, u should keep in mind that lower is the bitrate more hardwork on encoder so lower the production of frame, whenever u have to
is the the transcoder
and stream then there must be good balance of bitrate, most of the time selection of bitrate is done by system to be used.
Try -avcodec copy for not transcoding.
-Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity. _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
_______________________________________________ ffmpeg-user mailing list ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
Please dont top post, your mail is too hard to understand. It is 12 packet are sent at once, this is related to block size or some time said page size. This is assumed by rtp protocol. please provide me any libray refrence where you have seen That rtp is not giving 12 packet. I have used proprietary rtp library they also gave 12 packet. Though I have not read rfc of rtp. -Anshul -- Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
participants (2)
-
Anshul -
the...