FFprobe V7/8 failure to read HDR Dolby Video
Hi lovely FFmpeg team! We just upgraded an Ubuntu server running automations for the BFI National Archive from FFmpeg v4.4.2 to FFmpeg v7.1.1, then v8.0. We have HDR Dolby Vision JPEG2000 MXF files from an external supplier that automations using FFprobe v4 already partially processed, but which in v7 and v8 are being rejected with this message (returning exit status 1): [mxf @ 0xfefa0f7b0600 ] error reading header metadata N_10683320_06of20.mxf: Invalid data found when processing input FFprobe v4 does raise a couple of warnings (returns exit status 0): [mxf @ 0x55e53763c840 ] wrapping of stream 0 is unknown [mxf @ 0x55e53763c840 ] IndexSID 129 segment 0 has invalid IndexExitRate Our automation scripts capture the exit status 0 as a sign of file readability/health so the FFppeg upgrade these files are not progressing - no doubt for good reason. I’d be interested to know more about this failure please and how we might get them progressing through FFmpeg. I attach metadata text files from MediaInfo, regular and mediatrace. I'm sorry but we cannot supply the source files, but happy to extract any other metadata you may need to aid diagnosis. Thank you for this amazing software — it’s such a saviour for AV archiving generally! Joanna Joanna White (she/her) Knowledge, Learning & Collections Developer BFI National Archive Kingshill Way, Berkhamsted HP4 3TP joanna.white@bfi.org.uk<mailto:joanna.white@bfi.org.uk> The British Film Institute is governed by Royal Charter and is a charity registered in England and Wales number 287780. The contents of this e-mail are confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, kindly notify the sender that you have received this message in error and immediately delete it. Unless you are the intended recipient, you may not forward this e-mail to anybody, nor make any use of its contents.
We just upgraded an Ubuntu server running automations for the BFI National Archive from FFmpeg v4.4.2 to FFmpeg v7.1.1, then v8.0. We have HDR Dolby Vision JPEG2000 MXF files from an external supplier that automations using FFprobe v4 already partially processed, but which in v7 and v8 are being rejected with this message (returning exit status 1): [mxf @ 0xfefa0f7b0600 ] error reading header metadata
N_10683320_06of20.mxf: Invalid data found when processing input
FFprobe v4 does raise a couple of warnings (returns exit status 0): [mxf @ 0x55e53763c840 ] wrapping of stream 0 is unknown [mxf @ 0x55e53763c840 ] IndexSID 129 segment 0 has invalid IndexExitRate Our automation scripts capture the exit status 0 as a sign of file readability/health so the FFppeg upgrade these files are not progressing - no doubt for good reason. I’d be interested to know more about this failure please and how we might get them progressing through FFmpeg. I attach metadata text files from MediaInfo, regular and mediatrace. I'm sorry but we cannot supply the source files, but happy to extract any other metadata you may need to aid diagnosis.
Hi Joanna, have you already tried running the IMF Package through more format-targeted tools like Photon and ASDCPlib? Did these flag any issues? I'm skeptical about a few all-zero values where I would usually expect a valid UUIDv4 in the verbose header output you have attached to your message. Best regards, Erik
Hi Joanna, have you already tried running the IMF Package through more format-targeted tools like Photon and ASDCPlib? Did these flag any issues? I'm skeptical about a few all-zero values where I would usually expect a valid UUIDv4 in the verbose header output you have attached to your message. Best regards, Erik Hi Erik, Thanks for responding. Yes we’ve been through a procurement phase with the supplier and validated the IMF packages and the individual OP-1a MXF files. We use ICE to run these validation checks and they pass on all counts. Would you recommend different software to check the files? Thanks, Joanna The British Film Institute is governed by Royal Charter and is a charity registered in England and Wales number 287780. The contents of this e-mail are confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, kindly notify the sender that you have received this message in error and immediately delete it. Unless you are the intended recipient, you may not forward this e-mail to anybody, nor make any use of its contents.
participants (2)
-
Erik Dobberkau -
Joanna White